[Nerf] The Creator [Finished]

so is this [Finished] or what?

Eh, it's in a deadlock (see post #203 for tally).

Vote: Revert and nerf life gain (in addition to my previous votes), as per previous reasoning and also because jesus 30 life is and always has been crazy.

That doesn't break the tie though, does it? That would make it 9/9/8.

That is correct.

...wow, I'm kinda stupid, huh? I didn't realize you could possibly be voting for any other reason. Yeah, disregard me.

Tally, as it stands:
-30 life (1): NOLDER
-20 life (5): MooNFisH, masa, Haplo_64, Tamdrik, Aldgar Omk
-10 life (9): MooNFisH, masa, Ultros, Blue_Elite, bubbleman, Haplo_64, Andriex, Tamdrik, E-mouse
revert (9): ChrisAsmadi, Noodle, countspatula, Jayrulzz, Vincent, Ace_rockz, Sol, Xforce akujintails
revert and nerf attack gain (4): Nacho, MooNFisH, bubbleman, Jessica Stryker
revert and nerf life gain (8): NOLDER, MooNFisH, Ultros, Blue_Elite, Jessica Stryker, Serith, E-mouse, masamunemaniac

Since we need tie breakers, let's look at this differently:

Nerf to life (11): Aldgar Omk, Andriex, Blue_Elite, bubbleman, E-mouse, Haplo_64, masa, MooNFisH, NOLDER, Tamdrik, Ultros
Plain revert (9): ChrisAsmadi, Noodle, countspatula, Jayrulzz, Vincent, Ace_rockz, Sol, Xforce akujintails
Revert with additional nerf (10): NOLDER, MooNFisH, Ultros, Blue_Elite, Jessica Stryker, Serith, E-mouse, masamunemaniac, Nacho, bubbleman

I realize now that I'm simply trying to find reasons to rule out the plain revert. Ironically, this tally is convincing enough for me. I'm not sure it is to everyone though (I can think of at least 9 people who won't be convinced by it).

If you need a tie braeker, Vote: -10 life or revert and -life gain

Reasoning: Ultros.

Vote: Revert and change ability to +20 life until end of turn.

reasoning Ultros.

Vote: Revert and change ability to +20 life until end of turn.

reasoning Ultros.

Vote: Revert and change ability to +20 life until end of turn. Withdrawing my vote from the life nerf. Both the life nerf and the plain revert have a lot of support, and rather than continuing to have the two sides argue against each other, I think its best to come to a compromise. We're all just trying to do what we think is best for the game, after all.

vote: nerf -10 life

You need a reason.

And is anyone else amazed we've spent 12 pages arguing over 1 card?

Not amazed in the slightest.

12 pages and two months.

And yet I could have sworn that we've only spent 5 pages on the subject.

Yep, that sounds about right.

Individual votes:

NOLDER: -30 life; revert and nerf life gain
Nacho: -10 life; revert and nerf life gain
ChrisAsmadi: revert
MooNFisH: -10 life; -20 life; revert and nerf attack gain; revert and nerf life gain
masa: revert and nerf life gain
Noodle: revert and nerf life gain
countspatula: revert
Ultros: revert and nerf life gain
Blue_Elite: -10 life; revert and nerf life gain
bubbleman: -10 life; revert and nerf attack gain
Jayrulzz: revert
Haplo_64: -10 life; -20 life
Andriex: -10 life
Vincent: revert
Tamdrik: -10 life; -20 life
Ace_rockz: revert
Jessica Stryker: revert and nerf attack gain; revert and nerf life gain
Sol: revert
Xforce: revert
akujintails: revert
Aldgar Omk: -20 life
Serith: revert and nerf life gain
E-mouse: -10 life; revert and nerf life gain

Tally by preferred nerf:

-30 life (1): NOLDER
-20 life (4): MooNFisH, Haplo_64, Tamdrik, Aldgar Omk
-10 life (8): Nacho, MooNFisH, Blue_Elite, bubbleman, Haplo_64, Andriex, Tamdrik, E-mouse
revert (8): ChrisAsmadi, countspatula, Jayrulzz, Vincent, Ace_rockz, Sol, Xforce akujintails
revert and nerf attack gain (3): MooNFisH, bubbleman, Jessica Stryker
revert and nerf life gain (10): NOLDER, Nacho, MooNFisH, masa, Noodle, Ultros, Blue_Elite, Jessica Stryker, Serith, E-mouse

so does revert and nerf life gain win?

It would seem that way, yes.