1mana monsters

nekomasa Wrote:Also I blame Tamdrik for not putting a "not suitable for generated monsters" disclaimer on that idea.

I considered immediately after posting to add a "of course, for generated monsters, you should probably only use into play or on death abilities unless they're weak even as tokens", but I figured people could figure that out on their own. : p

---

Anyway, I think Lowly Slime's proposed ability is too weak.  I suggest making it 50% of its attack/life.  Otherwise, it's still pretty worthless.  At least this way, if you let it accrue Champ bonuses for a bit, it might be worthwhile.

For Melrak Follower, how about nerfing it to 12/6 and adding Invisible Attack?  Seems kind of appropriate, given how they seem to infiltrate everything.  If you think that's too powerful, keep in mind it's not entrenching.

Holy Acolyte and Fairy are okay, I suppose.  Acolyte could probably stand to be a little better, though.  4 life/turn is really freaking trivial.  Remember it still costs a card and occupies a slot.  At least make it beefier while you're at it (7/25?).

Evil Soldier could easily be 8 damage without overpowering it.  Probably 10-12 if it doesn't work while being attacked.

As for K-Army Guy, I like the "destroy to undizzy Khrima" version better than the "make heroes tired" version.

I like the Skyrian proposal (target facedown effect is flipped up).

Kelar Citizen: That's fine, but boost its stats a bit, too.  Maybe 15/15.

Gremlin's "death causes 5 damage" is okay, but I was thinking something like "Into play: Dizzy all opponent's effects."  Note this wouldn't trigger with Gremlin Pit, and it wouldn't spike the effects, just temporarily enervate the ones with activated abilities, like maybe to break a SWIMSUIT/Silver Arrow lock for one turn.  The other reason I want an ability like this is that, well, that's what gremlins do, right?  Muck with things, causing them not to work?

Skeleton: Seems kind of weak.  I think I would probably rather have it around to deal 18 damage again or sac for 2 than to mill one card and blow up.  I kind of like the old suggestion of "On death: Add a Magic Skull to your hand", maybe with zero sac.

Lokar Guard: Seems okay, if not especially useful.  Frankly, if it were 1, without losing the ability, it would probably be fine.  Heh.  Maybe with block dizzy.  "Go fetch help!"  By the way, at one time, weren't we discussing replacing the cumbersome "does not undizzy next turn" verbiage with a symbol similar to the dizzy star?  Like a little red X next to (or on top of) the star in the activation cost?  

Mubble: Probably okay.  Definitely not too powerful, even with Mubble Woods.  They're just too wimpy on their own.