1mana monsters

webrunner Wrote:I think the stat changes are extremly minor and don't need to be covered as early. Maybe go through the 2 costers first, and then do the 1 and 2 coster stats together (because if you're 'afraid' of getting into 2 coster territory, what happens if later the '2 coster territory' changes when you do the 2 costers?)

The stat changes will get covered at a later point.

azulknight Wrote:I'm not sure where I heard it, but I remember someone saying that the gremlins of CMC were specifically not mischief-loving imps... And we have the niche card aspect.

If azulknight heard correctly (which could be verified by asking webrunner), then a device related ability would be unflavourful.

webrunner Wrote:I would prefer if the 1/2 mana proposals didn't specifically use other specific cards (excepting themselves, i suppose): no kel'sor, no manamancer.

And it would be a specific hoser, working with only a specific few cards.

azulknight Wrote:...? I thought the .cscs changed before the immunity, bounce/dizzy, and dark elf-boost were introduced? Also, I approve all of those if they're going to be used.

Azul is correct - webrunner can't well introduce the abilities prior to us suggesting them, can he?

Anyway, I guess webrunner just wanted to try out a few different things, and maybe find a home for the new temporary ability status effects he made. Yeah, it might not have worked too well, but the abilities aren't stuck. We have continued this balance thread since the update of the cscs, and webrunner's still contributed (and as such acknowledged that there may be need for change), so the complained about abilities are not in any way set in stone.